I Was Always Curious Why My Mother Hated Her Neighbor, but When He Died, I Found Out the Real Reason – Story of the Day

Share this:

I drove down the familiar road, my heart pounding in my chest. As I pulled up to my childhood home, a wave of emotions slammed into me. The house stood there like a stubborn old soldier — a little worn out but still strong.

Stepping out of the car, I breathed in the scent of the garden — flowers mixed with the faint smell of old wood. It was like stepping straight into the past.

Memories rushed over me, one after another, pulling me deeper into a world I thought I had left behind. I hadn’t been here in years, not since that awkward family gathering that felt more like a chore than a celebration.

Back then, I was too busy with my own life — my job, my friends, my dreams. Everything seemed so urgent. It was easy to stay away, especially because my mother, Susan, and I had never been close.

Susan was tough. She had strong opinions and a temper that could explode like a firecracker. As a kid, talking to her was like walking through a minefield. When I grew up, things didn’t get any better. Our talks were short, stiff, and usually ended in arguments over the smallest things.

It was just easier to stay away.

But over time, I noticed changes in her.

During phone calls, she complained about how hard it was to keep the house clean, how grocery shopping exhausted her. Her voice, once sharp and commanding, sounded tired and slow.

That’s when I knew — it was time. I had to bring her closer to me, somewhere she would be safe and cared for.

Strangely, she didn’t argue. She only agreed after her neighbor, Jeremy, passed away. A man she had despised for as long as I could remember.

I never understood why.

When I was little, she would scold me, saying, “Stay away from Jeremy’s yard, Lisa! You hear me? Never go near him!”

It was confusing. Jeremy had always been nice to me — smiling warmly, waving from across the fence.

Eventually, I stopped asking why she hated him so much. It was just one of those strange family rules.

With my bags weighing down my arms, I took a deep breath and headed up the steps to the front door.

The paint was peeling, and the door creaked loudly as I pushed it open. Instantly, the smell of old wood and lavender surrounded me, wrapping around me like a familiar blanket.

Then came my mother’s unmistakable voice from upstairs.

“Lisa, is that you?” she shouted.

“Yeah, Mom! Are you packing already?” I called back, trying to sound cheerful.

“I still need time! Clean up the first floor!” she snapped.

I peered up the staircase, wondering if I should offer to help.

“How about I help you, Mom? It’ll go faster,” I offered hopefully.

“No!” she barked. “Did you hear me? Stay out of here! I’ll do it myself!”

I sighed, unsurprised. Susan had always been stubborn — about everything. Fighting her over something simple like packing wasn’t worth it.

“Alright, Mom,” I muttered under my breath, rolling my eyes as I set my bags down.

The living room hadn’t changed much. The same cluttered shelves, the same family photos.

One photo caught my eye — a picture of Mom, Dad, and me on a forgotten vacation.

I stared at it for a moment. I didn’t look much like Dad — not his posture, not his deep brown eyes.

My eyes were green. I’d noticed that difference when I was young, but I never dared ask about it.

Dad had died in a tragic accident when I was just a kid. After that, it was just me and Mom, and she barely spoke about him. All I had were these dusty photographs.

Gently, I placed the photo into a box and wandered into my old bedroom.

It still smelled the same — a mix of old books and childhood dreams.

I opened the wardrobe and smiled when I spotted a familiar little face peeking out.

Mr. Peebles.

My old teddy bear, worn and a little lopsided, but still precious.

Jeremy had given me that bear when I was small. I still remembered his kind smile the day he handed it to me.

But when Mom found out, she was furious.

“You are grounded! And you throw that thing away!” she had yelled.

I had cried and hidden Mr. Peebles in the back of my wardrobe instead. And he had stayed there, quietly waiting all these years.

Holding him now, brushing off the dust, I felt a heavy weight of curiosity.

Why had she hated Jeremy so much?

Restless, I walked back to the staircase.

“Mom! How much longer?” I called.

“An hour! Maybe more!” she hollered back.

I rolled my eyes.

“I’ll go for a walk, then!” I shouted.

“Fine! But don’t wander too far!” she warned.

“Mom, I’m 42!” I called back, half laughing.

“Old habits,” she grumbled.

I stepped outside, feeling the cool breeze brush against my face.

My eyes wandered to Jeremy’s house.

It stood lonely, empty. Nobody had claimed it. No family. No one.

Something tugged at my heart.

Before I could stop myself, I crossed the street.

I turned the doorknob — and to my surprise, it creaked open easily.

“Hello?” I called into the empty house.

Silence answered.

I walked in slowly, feeling like an intruder and yet… somehow like I belonged.

Dust covered everything, but the house still had a strange warmth.

Upstairs, I found Jeremy’s bedroom.

It was simple — just a bed by the window and a small table beside it.

On the table was a box, dusty and worn. I brushed off the top and froze.

Written in neat handwriting were the words: “For Lisa.”

My heart jumped into my throat.

Was it for me?

My hands shook as I lifted the lid.

Inside were letters, old photographs, and a battered journal.

I picked up a photo — and gasped.

It was Jeremy — young, smiling — with his arm around my mother.

They looked happy. Really happy.

I sat on the bed, my mind spinning.

I opened the journal and flipped through the pages, desperate for answers.

One entry stopped me cold.

“Today was my dear Lisa’s eleventh birthday. Susan is still angry with me. I don’t blame her. When she found out she was pregnant, I ran away. I was scared. I regret it every single day. If only I had been braver for my little girl.”

Tears blurred my vision.

He had been writing about me.

More entries followed:

“Today, I gave Lisa a teddy bear. She named him Mr. Peebles. Seeing her hug it nearly broke me. But Susan will be furious. Lisa might never be allowed to talk to me again.”

It all made sense now.

The kindness. The bear. The anger.

Jeremy was my real father.

I reached the bottom of the box and found a sealed letter.

My fingers trembled as I opened it.

“Dear Lisa,
If you’re reading this, I’m gone.
Please know I loved you from the moment I knew you existed. I was a coward back then, but not a day went by that I didn’t think of you.
Don’t blame your mother. She protected you the best she could.
I’m leaving everything I have — the house, my savings — to you. My only family.
Love,
Jeremy.”

I pressed the letter to my chest, sobbing quietly.

After a while, I wiped my eyes, folded the letter carefully, and tucked it into my coat pocket.

I walked back to my mother’s house, the truth heavy in my heart.

She was already waiting on the porch, her suitcase by her side.

“Lisa! Where were you?” she asked, frowning. “I’ve been ready for ten minutes!”

When she saw my tear-streaked face, her expression softened.

“Lisa, honey, are you alright?” she asked, sounding almost… worried.

“Yeah, Mom. Just… got some dust in my eyes,” I lied, forcing a smile. “Took a while to wash it out. Anyway… shall we go?”

She looked at me carefully, then nodded.

“Yes, let’s go, honey. I don’t want to live here anymore. There’s nothing left for me here.”

“I agree, Mom,” I said quietly, meaning it more than she could ever know. “Don’t worry. I’ll take care of you.”

We loaded the car, packed it full of the life we were leaving behind.

As we drove away, I glanced back at the houses — the one I grew up in and the one that held the answers I had needed my whole life.

It was over.

But it was also a beginning.

Finally, I knew the truth.

And even though it came late… it was better late than never.